For how long can you bear your child´s cry?

by Marilia Di Cesare on October 25, 2010

There are a number of reasons for babies and children to cry: express a need, pain, tiredness, frustration, missing mommy or simply spill emotions. Many times it´s useless to try to soothe their crying for it can lead to even more crying. Many times their need is simply to cry.

Whenever around a child crying, adults try to make her stop crying. But when we rush to the crying child and somehow make her stop crying, we might be impeding her to soothe herself or simply let her feelings go. We have tons of techniques to make children stop crying but what if all they need is to cry for a while?

We have to be more used to validating their feelings

When a child cries for seeing her mother leaving the room, we should just validate her feelings and say something like: “I understand you are upset because your mom left, but she will come back”. That´s it, let the child cry for a while and that will probably be just seconds or minutes, harder on us to listen then on them who need to relieve their upset feelings crying (and don´t need being distracted).

Janet Lansbury put it nicely in one of her posts: “If we can give them the space and time to express painful feelings instead of arresting their cries, and if we can steady ourselves to work through our own discomfort, then our children can be reassured that their true responses are accepted and appropriate”.

A personal example is that I´ve been listening to Luísa crying almost every single day when she comes back from school. She comes home very tired after a lot of interactions and activities for four hours in the morning. And as soon as she walks in the house, she starts complaining and crying and there is simply nothing I can do to help her out of it.

I learned to accept it and let her release the morning tensions her way: crying and screaming.

I´m ok with this now, but it was hard for me in the beginning. I would try to comfort her in any way I could. Most of my attempts would be a disaster, because there really wasn´t anything I could do. The only thing she needs is to cry in peace for a while.

I guess it took me about a year to let go trying to soothe her. It was especially hard for me to take this perfectly normal behavior when I had guests at home. Guests staying over would be nervous by her crying/screaming at lunch time, wondering what we could do, trying to help to make her comfortable and sometimes being confused by my let it be attitude.

When having our screaming-every-day-at-twelve routine shared with someone else, I´d feel tremendously insecure with my decision to just let her be. I would be influenced by the guest´s nervousness, trying to soothe Luísa, causing even more stress.

I realized that having guests at lunch time would add to my insecurities as a mother, but now that I´m aware of what´s going on, I can simply tell the guests to let her scream and cry for a while and if that makes them nervous then it´s fine if they want to be away.

I had a skype talk with Tara last week and we talked about it. It was comforting to hear from her that it was nice for Luísa to have a safe place to lose it, since she probably tries hard to fit in at school.

Crying with mommy (or sometimes screaming at mommy) can be so reassuring for a child. It was so good to talk with Tara, because as though I´ve been feeling that letting Luísa cry and struggle a little (or a lot) is fine, most adults that I relate to will try to help me to fix her behavior.

Is crying and screaming a behavior to be fixed at all times? No. Screaming a bit at home doesn´t mean that she is not being educated. On the contrary, in this specific case it´s helping by letting her liberate her feelings and by not repressing what´s natural.

Children have the right to cry after all. We must find a way to calm down our necessity to soothe them right away. We have to get more used to let them cry a bit (or a lot). They need it. They need the space to release their emotions freely. Otherwise, we might be teaching them not to listen to their feelings, to replace them by some activity, rationalize too much. We don´t want this, right?

Photo Credit



{ 14 comments… read them below or add one }

Janet October 25, 2010 at 3:08 pm

Marila, this is beautifully said. Thank you for the link and the reminder! This is just what I needed to read first thing this morning after a rough evening with one of my children. It is so challenging to hear the feelings and not rush to “fix” them. It is wonderful to begin giving the gift of acceptance of ALL our child’s feelings in infancy and toddlerhood, because this dynamic needs to continue…as was demonstrated to me last night with my 13 year old. It doesn’t get easier to hear the sadness, but in my heart I know it’s the right thing to do to just hold on, hug and listen.

Reply

Marilia October 25, 2010 at 3:30 pm

Thank you Janet. It´s nice to know that even an older child, like your 13 year old (not a child anymore) still needs room for this acceptance. I guess we have to be reminding each other of this right thing to do “hold on, hug and listen”.

Reply

Erica October 25, 2010 at 4:41 pm

Great post. I agree – it’s important to let children let their feelings out. I definitely try to do this when my daughter is frustrated that she can’t do something that she wants to do. Sometimes she tries to bang her head on things. I try to just give her a pillow or make sure she’s safe and let her get those feelings out.

Reply

Marilia October 25, 2010 at 5:59 pm

That´s awesome that you can give your daughter a pillow when she gets in the banging-her-head mood!

Reply

Cecilia October 25, 2010 at 4:53 pm

I agree with this too. I know that even I definitely have times when I just need to cry! It makes me feel better but I know it makes my husband anxious to see my cry. I feel especially strongly about this because I have a boy, and you can bet that he gets those “Stop crying!” instructions alot. But it’s like saying, “Stop feeling!” We do need to teach him socially appropriate ways to handle his emotions, but there are times, like in the privacy of his own home, when he’ll need to decompress and just feel without being judged.

Found your blog via your comments to me. I’m enjoying it!

Reply

Marilia October 25, 2010 at 5:57 pm

I can see how this must be harder to do with a boy Cecilia, letting him cry. I can only guess now that mothers of boys need to be even stronger to make room for their cry, since it´s so easy for us to fall in the stereotype´s trap that boys don´t cry.

Thanks for coming back to my blog. I´m all about supporting the Mom Renewal comunity.

Reply

Tara October 25, 2010 at 4:59 pm

*love*

And yes, it’s hard. Partially because we’re mamas and we hurt when our babies hurt. But maybe that’s just what they need, to know we’re there with them while their “in it”.

Reply

Marilia October 25, 2010 at 6:01 pm

Yes, it all comes down to their biggest need: us there.

Reply

Ma October 26, 2010 at 2:43 am

Maaaaaa what can I say, really? first of all congrats on your new project, it absolutely rocks as well as you do. You so rock as a (not-so-single) Mom and parenting isn’t a picnic, that’s for sure. But I could see with my own eyes, and moreover I could feel that you are bringing up sweet Luisa with such respect, freedom in a nest flooded with love. Can she get even luckier? I hope so. And I hope you do too if you know what I mean.. lol.. considering that our TOP5 qualities ever dreamed in our soul mates aren’t exactly about physical features only. Anyway, back to parenting topic. I loved this last post and thanks for sharing your thoughts…I’m pretty sure they’ll be very useful to me when I venture into these wild and sweet waters of parenthood.

Reply

Marilia October 26, 2010 at 10:04 am

Thank you Ma, I´m glad you like this all. Did you mean that by luckier I´ll have a man? Well, that can be great, but for now, trully, I´m very happy, read my previous post: 5 reasons why being a single mom rocks and you´ll know why.

Thanks a lot for saying that I bring up Luísa with “respect, freedom and in a nest flooded with love”, it feels great to read this. It´s really all I want to offer Luísa.

Reply

Liz October 29, 2010 at 2:20 am

I read this last night in the wee hours as I was rocking my son (5.5 months) and was able to put it to use today!

I had an awesome day with my son and daughter (29 months) and she ended up skipping her nap. Well by 5 pm she was a wreck and everything she did, she then wanted to do the opposite and ended up having a total meltdown tantrum of epic proportions. In the past I would have tried to comfort her or even had her sit in her special spot for when she yells and screams in the house (because I really can’t stand that so she sits on the floor and I typically count to 30 and she’s all good after that) but today I just let her go.

I was trying to prep dinner and she was flailing and crying and screaming and I just kept saying “I know you’re upset and I’m sorry, it’s totally ok, just take the time you need to get it out.” After a few minutes she sat down in her seat at the table and asked for some apple and then was totally fine and we had a nice dinner together and then watched a Halloween DVD before reading some books before bed.

Thank you so much for putting this into perspective for me!!! I will try to practice this more often in the future. Wonderful post.

Reply

Marilia October 29, 2010 at 11:29 am

Thank you Liz, for coming back with your sucessful story of validating and helping your child getting her feelings out.

It makes me really happy to know that my story can help others. And I´m sure that if anyone else reads this, they can get some helpful insights by your example as well.

Reply

Jenna December 22, 2010 at 2:15 pm

When my daughter gets overly frusterated or hurt all she wants to do is lay her head on me and cry for a little bit. People panic, trying to figure out all these different ways to make her stop… usually it involves doing something silly to try and make her laugh but it just pisses her off even more (I think she doesn’t like being patronized). I try to tell them, it’s ok, she’s hurt, just let her cry for a little bit. If you were sad about something and people kept making funny faces at you and saying “you’re fine, you’re fine”, you’d probably smack them.

Sure enough, after a good cry she gets up and is fine again. Sometimes we all just need to cry, kids are no different.

Reply

Marilia Di Cesare December 22, 2010 at 6:23 pm

Absolutely. My daughter also hates when people on the street say how beautiful she is or touch her head, or ask for a kiss, or a smile and all that (people that she has no intimacy at all). She gets so pissed off and some people get annoyed saying that she is not that beautiful anymore and stuff like that. What the heck? Come and ask ME for a hug and a kiss.

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: